Research Strategies and Validity — Comparing Methods and Understanding Threats to Accuracy | Chapter 6 of Research Methods for the Behavioral Sciences

Chapter 6 of Research Methods for the Behavioral Sciences examines the five major research strategies used in psychology and the behavioral sciences. It also highlights the importance of validity—the degree to which a study’s results are accurate and generalizable. This chapter not only defines the different strategies but also explains how researchers manage the trade-off between internal and external validity while addressing common threats such as bias, confounding variables, and artifacts.

Watch the complete breakdown above and subscribe to Last Minute Lecture for more clear, chapter-based study guides.

The Five Research Strategies

Each research strategy is suited for different questions about behavior and relationships:

• Descriptive research: Provides detailed observations of behavior but does not test relationships or causation.
• Correlational research: Examines statistical relationships between variables but cannot determine cause and effect.
• Experimental research: Uses manipulation, control, and random assignment to establish causality.
• Quasi-experimental research: Tests cause-and-effect relationships but lacks random assignment or full control, limiting internal validity.
• Nonexperimental research: Compares groups or conditions without manipulation, often used when experiments are impractical or unethical.

Defining Strategy, Design, and Procedure

The chapter distinguishes between:

• Research strategy: The general approach used to address a research question.
• Research design: The overall structure that specifies variables, groups, and measurements.
• Research procedure: The step-by-step methods for conducting the study.

Internal vs. External Validity

Internal validity refers to the degree to which a study establishes a clear cause-and-effect relationship, free of confounds. External validity reflects how well findings generalize beyond the study to other people, settings, and times. Researchers must often balance these two forms of validity, as increasing control in experiments can reduce generalizability.

Threats to Validity

Many factors can undermine the accuracy of research:

• Selection bias: Differences between groups that exist before treatment begins.
• Volunteer bias: Participants who volunteer may differ systematically from the population.
• Participant variables: Individual characteristics like age, motivation, or intelligence can affect outcomes.
• Confounding variables: Uncontrolled factors that create alternative explanations for results.

Artifacts and Research Integrity

Beyond sampling and design, uncontrolled artifacts can distort findings:

• Experimenter bias: When the researcher’s expectations influence participants or results.
• Demand characteristics: When participants guess the purpose of the study and change their behavior.
• Participant reactivity: Altered behavior due to awareness of being observed.

Balancing Validity in Research

A central theme of this chapter is the trade-off between internal validity (experimental control) and external validity (real-world generalization). Effective research carefully balances these concerns, ensuring both scientific rigor and meaningful applicability.

Conclusion

Chapter 6 highlights how research strategies guide the entire scientific process in psychology. By understanding the differences between descriptive, correlational, experimental, quasi-experimental, and nonexperimental strategies, and by recognizing threats to validity, researchers can design stronger studies. Ethical awareness of artifacts, confounding variables, and biases ensures that results are both accurate and useful in advancing behavioral science.

For more insights, watch the full video summary above and explore the full series of chapters: Research Methods for the Behavioral Sciences Playlist.

If you found this breakdown useful, don’t forget to subscribe to Last Minute Lecture for more chapter-by-chapter study guides and textbook summaries.